Home / Women's / Winners and losers out of the NCAA women’s singles draw selection

Winners and losers out of the NCAA women’s singles draw selection

Photo by Erez Aidlin

The talent in the NCAA women’s draw feels pretty well distributed throughout, with not too many of the favorites clumped together, despite some questionable seeding results.

At first glance, a few early matchups stand out. For starters, No. 1 seed Mimi Xu (Duke) will have to face the wonky underhand serve of preseason No. 42 Kyoka Kubo (Kansas). How will she handle that unconventional approach? If Xu gets through that match, she will likely have a relatively safe path to the quarterfinals. There’s also plenty of uncertainty regarding college tennis vets who have struggled and the young guns. 

Winners

Emma Dong

No. 8 seed Emma Dong (Georgia) was awarded a favorable path in Georgia’s last chance to claim a home singles title for a decade. She opens the tournament versus unranked Esha Velaga (Penn), with potential subsequent opponents including No. 56 Julia Zhu (Kentucky) in the Round of 32 and Arina Malygina (Oklahoma State) in the Round of 16. Malygina, a freshman, has been red-hot, but still could show some signs of youth in the biggest college tournament of her career. Dong would face No. 2 seed Amelie Van Impe (SMU) in the quarters — not a world beater — and has a realistic path to the semis. From there, she’s just a few matches from the title.

Rose Nijkamp 

No. 6 seed Rose Marie Nijkamp (Texas) will likely not face a challenge until the Round of 16 as her early opponents include Michigan freshman hopeful No. 116 Olivia Traynor, and either No. 118 Vilma Krebs-Hyllested (San Diego) or Alice Battesti (Ole Miss). Possibly facing 9-16 seed Sophia Cisse-Ignatiev (Ohio State) in the Round of 16, she could prove to be a tough opponent but Nijkamp should still be a level above the Buckeye. The Nijkamp v. No. 1 seed Mimi Xu(Duke) would be an exciting quarterfinal, a potential matchup we missed out on from All Americans.

Mia Slama

It seemed like preseason No. 10 Mia Slama (NC State) got slighted out of a seed as she qualified at All Americans and has one of the highest UTRs in the field, but she ended up with the last laugh. Her path to the quarterfinals seems fairly light, with the best player standing in her way being one that she beat authoritatively at All Americans. No. 7 seed Kaitlyn Carnicella (South Carolina) would be her Round of 16 matchup. Slama won that match versus Carnicella 7-5, 2-6, 6-0. Early opponents include Andrea Nova (Ole Miss) and likely No. 109 Salakthip Ounmang (Oklahoma).

Nao Nishino

No. 39 Nao Nishino (Ohio State) had a great run at All Americans before getting trounced by Xu in the semifinals. All of her other wins came there in straight sets versus No. 21 Tatum Evans (UNC), No. 10 Slama and the rock solid Patricija Paukstyte (Georgia). She will face Lily Taylor (Arizona State) in the first round, and will likely face 9-16 seed Alexis Nguyen (UNC) or Stephanie Yakoff (Harvard) in the Round of 16 — solid opponents that could give Nishino some trouble but you’d likely still put plenty of faith in the Buckeye to get it done.

Losers

Katie Rolls

Out of all the 9-16 seeded players, Katie Rolls (Virginia) probably got the toughest draw, just going by face value. She drew preseason No. 6 Piper Charney (Michigan) in the first round, and will then likely face No. 29 Alyssa Ahn. Both of those potential matchups are honestly toss-ups. Who’d be next? The clear favorite No. 4 seed Luciana Perry (Ohio State). Brutal stuff for Rolls. If she even just gets to the quarterfinals, she should get some kind of award.

Kaitlyn Carnicella

By the same token that Slama got a favorable draw, No. 7 seed Kaitlyn Carnicella is in a tough section. Her opening match versus Maryboyce Deatherage (Florida State) is likely a W, but she may be tested in the second round as she faces Theodora Rabman (UNC) or Pauksteyte. If she gets through that, she will have a chance to avenge her loss to Slama, and be immediately met with the tournament favorite.

Tagged:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get the latest from Division1Tennis.com.